首页
电影
新闻
新片
热映
排行榜
影评
专题
电影查询
电视
新闻
新剧
热播
排行榜
电视剧查询
人物
新闻
八卦
人物访谈
排行榜
视频
图片
博客
电影电视
明星时尚
文化生活
相册
会员
群组
我的同城
活动
热门话题
群组分类
群组人气榜
游戏
问答游戏
图片评分
电影院
你现在的位置:首页>>群组>>天堂电影小组>>一些英美知名影评人的top 10 lists

一些英美知名影评人的top 10 lists

加入收藏 已经被10位会员收藏

2007-9-26 15:58:53

from:
 
 
Alexander Walker (1930-2003)



The most eloquent film critic of all time. Born in Northern Ireland and worked mainly fof the London based papaer, The Evening Standard. He wrote a number of books, of which 'It's only a movie Ingrid' was the best. He also wrote excellent biographies on Stanley Kubrick, Elizabeth Taylor and Vivien Leigh.

Alexander Walker's Top Ten Films

1. L'avventura (Antonioni)

2. Citizen Kane (Welles)

3. Dr. Strangelove (Kubrick)

4. La dolce vita (Fellini)

5. The 400 Blows (Truffaut)

6. The Leopard (Visconti)

7. Some Like It Hot (Wilder)

8. 2001: A Space Odyssey (Kubrick)

9. Taxi Driver (Scorsese)

10. Wild Strawberries (Bergman)



Pauline Kael
Pauline Kael (1919 - 2001)



Kael was an American film critic who wrote predominantly for The New Yorker magazine. She was known for her in-depth, well-informed, impassioned movie reviews. She approached movies emotionally (in sharp contrast to the "intellectual" preferences of her contemporaries), with a strongly vernacular writing style. Kael's guiding stance was that movies, regardless of other merits, must be entertaining. She is often, rightly regarded as the most influential American film critic of all time.

Pauline Kael's Favourite Films (no particular order)

1. Grand Illusion (Renoir)

2. Citizen Kane (Welles)

3. The Godfather (Coppola)

4. Bonnie & Clyde (Penn)

5. Jules & Jim (Truffaut)

6. Mean Streets (Scorsese)

7. Intolerance (Griffiths)

8. Last Tango In Paris (Bertolucci)

9. Smiles of a Summer Night (Bergman)

10. Nashville (Altman)



Roger Ebert
Roger Ebert (1942 -)



Ebert is an Emmy Award-nominated American author and film critic who began writing for the Chicago Sun-Times in 1967. His reviews are syndicated to over 200 newspapers in the U.S. and elsewhere. He is also a long-time co-host of a syndicated television program featuring his film criticism, first for 23 years with Gene Siskel and, since Siskel's death, with Richard Roeper on Ebert & Roeper. He has written more than 15 books, including his annual movie yearbook. In 1975, he became the first film critic to win a Pulitzer Prize for Criticism. Ebert has honorary degrees from the University of Colorado, the American Film Institute, and the School of the Art Institute of Chicago. In February 1995, Chicago's Erie Street was renamed Siskel & Ebert Way, near the CBS Studios. He also received a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame in June 2005, the first professional film critic to receive this honor.

Roger Ebert's Favourite Films

1. Aguirre, Wrath of God (Herzog)

2. Apocalypse Now (Coppola)

3. Citizen Kane (Welles)

4. Dekalog (Kieslowski)

5. La dolce vita (Fellini)

6. The General (Keaton)

7. Raging Bull (Scorsese)

8. 2001: A Space Odyssey (Kubrick)

9. Tokyo Story (Ozu)

10. Vertigo (Hitchcock)





David Thomson
David Thomson (1941 -)



Thomson is a noted film critic in the United States and the author of the much praised 'New Biographical Dictionary of Film'.He was a teacher of film studies at Dartmouth College and is a regular contributor to The New York Times, Film Comment, Movieline, The New Republic, Salon.com and The Independent. He has also served on the selection committee for the New York Film Festival and wrote the script for the award-winning documentary The Making of a Legend: Gone With the Wind.

David Thomson's Top Ten Film's

1. Blue Velvet (Lynch)

2. Celine and Julie Go Boating (Rivette)

3. Citizen Kane (Welles)

4. The Conformist (Bertolucci)

5. His Girl Friday (Hawks)

6. A Man Escaped (Bresson)

7. Pierrot le fou (Godard)

8. La R�gle du jeu (Renoir)

9. That Obscure Object of Desire (Bu�uel)

10. Ugetsu Monogatari (Mizoguchi)



James Agee
James Agee (1909 - 1955)



Agee was a Pulitzer Prize-winning American novelist, screenwriter, journalist, poet, and film critic. In the 1940s he was one of the most influential film critics in the U.S. His autobiographical novel, A Death in the Family (1957), won the author a posthumous Pulitzer Prize.

James Agee Favourite Films (no particular order)

1. Monsieur Verdoux (Chaplin)

2. It Happened One Night (Capra)

3. Red River (Hawks)

4. Lifeboat (Hitchcock)

5. Treasure Of Sierra Madre (Huston))

6. The Birth of a Nation (Griffith)

7. Zero De Conduite (Vigo)

8. Hamlet (Olivier)

9. The Curse Of The Cat People (Von Fritsch & Hawks)

10. L'Atalante (Vogo)



Andrew Sarris
Andrew Sarris (1928 -)



Sarris is a film critic and a leading proponent of the Auteur theory of criticism. He is generally credited with popularising this theory in America. He wrote the highly influential book The American Cinema: Directors and Directions 1929-1968, published in 1968, an opinionated assessment of films of the sound era, organized by director. The book was influential on other critics and helped raise an awareness of the role of the film director among the general public.

Andrew Sarris Favourite Films (no particular order)

1. Sunset Boulevard (Wilder)

2. The Magnificent Ambersons (Welles)

3. That Hamilton Woman (Korda)

4. Heavan Can Wait (Lubitsch)

5. The Godfather (Copolla))

6. Dressed To Kill (De Plama)

7. Barry Lyndon (Kubrick)

8. Merchant Of Four Seasons (Fassbinder)

9. The Chelsea Girls (Warhol & Morrissey)

10. 2001 a Space Odyssey (Kubrick)



Barry Norman
Barry Norman (1933 -)



Norman presented BBC1's Film programme from 1972, becoming the sole presenter the following year. Norman's stint was broken in 1982 by a brief unhappy spell presenting Omnibus. After returning to the Film series, Norman became increasingly annoyed by the BBC's reluctance to screen the programme at a regular time, and he accepted an offer in 1998 to work for BSkyB, where he remained for three years. Jonathan Ross took his place as the BBC programme's presenter. He is commonly associated with the catch-phrase "and why not?", which actually originated from his puppet likeness on the satirical show Spitting Image. Norman has since adopted the phrase himself, and it is the title of his autobiography. Norman has contributed a column to the Radio Times for many years, and has written a number of novels.

Barry Norman's Top Ten Films

1. Battleship Potemkin (Eisenstein)

2. Bringing Up Baby (Hawks)

3. Citizen Kane (Welles)

4. Paths of Glory (Kubrick)

5. Rashomon (Kurosawa)

6. La R�gle du jeu (Renoir)

7. The Searchers (Ford)

8. The Seventh Seal (Bergman)

9. Singin' in the Rain (Kelly, Donen)

10. Some Like It Hot (Wilder)



Derek Malcolm
Derek Malcolm (1932 -)



Malcoolm is a film critic and historian. He worked for several decades as a critic for the British newspaper The Guardian. Upon his retirement in 2000, he published his final series of articles, The Century of Films, in which he shared his favorite films from around the world. Currently he is president of the British Federation of Film Societies and the International Film Critics' Circle. In 2003 he published his excellent autobiography "Family Secrets"

Derek Malcolm's Top Ten Films 1. Dekalog (Kieslowski)

2. The Music Room (S. Ray)

3. Rio Bravo (Hawks)

4. The Seventh Seal (Bergman)

5. The Spirit of the Beehive (Erice)

6. The Story of the Late Chrysanthemums (Mizoguchi)

7. The Time to Live and the Time to Die (Hou)

8. Tokyo Story (Ozu)

9. Touch of Evil (Welles)

10. Tristana (Bunuel)



Anthony Lane
Anthony Lane (1962 -)



Lane has been a film reviewer on The New Yorker magazine since 1993. His writing has been frequently praised for its style and wit. (John Updike blurbed that he was "the fizziest critic around" and meant it as a compliment. Malcolm Gladwell has opined that he is "funnier than the funniest critics and smarter than the smartest critics."



Mark Kermode
Mark Kermode (1963)



Kermode is a British film critic who regularly writes for Sight and Sound magazine and The Observer newspaper. He is also a critic on other branches of the arts for the BBC2 programme Newsnight Review, and frequently appears on The Culture Show and BBC News 24. He is best known for reviewing and debating the new movie releases each Friday afternoon on Simon Mayo's BBC Radio Five Live show. While he gives many favourable critiques, it is his scathing 'rants' that are most memorable. His favourite film of all time is 'The Exorcist' and he is considered one of the world's leading authorities on that film, having written multiple editions of BFI Modern Classics: The Exorcist and contributed to many other publications and documentaries about it.

Mark Kermode's Top Ten Films

1. The Exorcist (Friedkin)

2. Brazil (Gilliam)

3. Citizen Kane (Welles)

4. The Devils (K. Russell)

5. Don't Look Now (Roeg)

6. Eyes without a Face (Franju)

7. It's a Wonderful Life (Capra)

8. Love and Death (Allen)

9. Mary Poppins (Stevenson)

10. The Seventh Seal (Bergman)

--------------------
24 Lies A Second
回复 举报

楼主

管理员给此话题奖励了 2 分!
2007-9-26 16:05:07

比较让我吃惊的是Sarris的选择。

个人感觉Heaven Can Wait只能算是Lubitsch的平庸之作,Merchant Of Four Seasons 也远不是Fassbinder的杰作。

--------------------
24 Lies A Second
回复 举报

1 楼

 
 
2007-9-26 16:34:42
影评人也有自己的口味嘛,呵呵
--------------------
人皆寻梦
2007-9-27 11:34:01
看了这个片子,觉得一般呀。
--------------------
芙蓉白面不过带肉之骷髅
 
 
2007-9-26 17:12:25

英文不好,看着好累

上榜的多是些老电影啊

公民凯恩的上榜率很高啊,还有第七封印和2001太空漫游

 

 

--------------------
your kisses,halleluya,take me to a mystical experience
回复 举报

2 楼

2007-9-27 9:46:11

看来专家都喜欢Citizen Kane,说实在的我没有太大的感觉....

--------------------
“银幕是一个如此神奇的媒介,它能在传达情绪与感情的同时仍然饶有趣味。我想这是任何其他形式的艺术所无法企及的。”
回复 举报

3 楼

2007-9-27 12:27:30

第一位的亚历山大·沃克好像对《搏击会》深恶痛绝

 

Pauline Kael与Andrew Sarris是世仇,而比尔怀尔德说Kael的影评全是垃圾,Sarris第一选择是日落大道。face

 

另外周黎明的偶像好像是Pauline Kael

 

 

--------------------
电影就像一扇梦幻之窗,你能从中看到的世界将比你生活的世界更有趣。
回复 举报

4 楼

2007-9-27 15:44:07
Pauline Kael喜欢马龙白兰度,讨厌库布里克是有名的。
--------------------
“银幕是一个如此神奇的媒介,它能在传达情绪与感情的同时仍然饶有趣味。我想这是任何其他形式的艺术所无法企及的。”
回复 举报

5 楼

2007-9-27 17:47:12

Kael的这个list大概是里面我觉得最好理解的,她推崇的是那批人文味道重的欧洲艺术电影,特别是60年代随着新浪潮一起进来的那些欧洲电影,还有就是新好莱坞的那些片子,Mean St与Nashville都是她多年来力挺的片子。

至于说她的影评,有一次我嫌得无聊把图书馆里她的影评集全都找来(4,5本吧),结果发现其中一大半片子我连名字都没听说过。然后翻我看过的电影,感觉屁话实在多,说了半天没几句我有兴趣的。从此反正再不看她的影评(当然其实之前也没怎么看过)

 

ps。这些list我就觉得Sarris不可理解。

--------------------
24 Lies A Second
回复 举报

6 楼

2007-9-27 20:48:48

Sarris的我倒还可以接受,不会和他口味差太多,而且这个也是没有名次高低的嘛.比如Welles、Korda、Lubitsch这些老导演肯定上任没问题,只不过是选片可能就个人点,当然一般影评人选这么个影史榜单肯定得要和别人有些不同,Warhol算和他一代人吧,选得还挺意外的,另外选了两Kubrick的,De Palma直接选Dressed to Kill,可能还要结合他具体影评,毕竟圆不圆还得看系铃人.

 

当然所谓的选影史杰作也就是个show罢了.

 

 

--------------------
www.mtime.com/blog/bigcinema/
回复 举报

7 楼

管理员给此回复奖励了 3 分!
 
 
2007-9-28 5:22:07
我就是觉得Lubitsch的片子里Heaven Can Wait实在有点排不上号。不知道他为什么喜欢这部。
--------------------
24 Lies A Second
2007-9-28 12:51:31
Heaven Can Wait确实是...哎~ 我猜Sarris可能看上了这部集了Lubitsch的诸多特点(不敢说大成),而且毕竟也是演了一家伙一辈子的事情,有点"总结"的意味在吧~ 当然完全可以选他的另一部Heaven~
--------------------
www.mtime.com/blog/bigcinema/
 
 
2007-9-28 11:08:28

Barry Norman好酷啊,竟然选了库布里克的Paths of Glory !

库布里克那么多经典里面选择这部说明他和我一样太face这个电影了!

--------------------
“银幕是一个如此神奇的媒介,它能在传达情绪与感情的同时仍然饶有趣味。我想这是任何其他形式的艺术所无法企及的。”
回复 举报

8 楼

 
 
2007-9-28 15:40:07
哈哈
--------------------
人皆寻梦
2007-9-28 15:58:57
一直放在那里没去看,看来得抓紧看看老
--------------------
电影就像一扇梦幻之窗,你能从中看到的世界将比你生活的世界更有趣。
 
 
2008-3-31 10:14:37

天堂可以等待,非常不错。

 

难怪CC找Sarris做那套碟花絮

--------------------
回复 举报

9 楼

我要回复

参与话题讨论,请先 注册登录